When two offers have different vesting schedules, the four-year total misleads you. Line the offers up by year instead. Write down what each one pays in years one, two, three and four. Count base, sign-on and the shares that vest that year. Then add up the years you actually expect to stay. A back-loaded grant pays little early and a lot late. A front-loaded grant does the reverse. So the same $400,000 grant can be worth very different money by the time you leave. Once the years are lined up, negotiate the weak years, not the total. Ask the back-loaded company to fill years one and two with sign-on. Ask the front-loaded company how refreshers cover years three and four. Then check the tax on your biggest vest year. This post follows one Android engineer with two offers that look close on paper.
Jordan’s two offers have different vesting schedules and look close in total
Take an Android engineer we’ll call Jordan. Jordan has two senior offers. Both include a $400,000 stock grant over four years. The numbers below are our own example. We leave out the annual bonus and assume a flat share price, to keep the math simple.
Offer A is back-loaded. Base is $180,000. The grant vests 5%, 15%, 40% and 40%. That’s the split a former Amazon recruiter described on Levels.fyi in a September 2022 post. Levels.fyi sells negotiation coaching. The post promotes it. The same post says the sign-on bonus usually covers the first two years. So Offer A adds $60,000 in year one and $45,000 in year two.
Offer B is front-loaded. Base is $185,000, with no sign-on. The grant vests 38%, 32%, 20% and 10%. Levels.fyi’s July 2024 roundup of vesting schedules calls that Google’s current schedule. Google’s own pages don’t confirm it. A schedule can also change in two years. So treat both splits as examples and read your own grant.
Divide each four-year total by four. Offer A comes to about $306,000 a year. Offer B comes to $285,000. On that average, Offer A looks $21,000 a year better.
Offer A doesn’t pull ahead until year four
Now split each offer by year. Offer A pays $260,000 in year one. That’s base, $60,000 of sign-on and $20,000 of vested stock. Year two pays $285,000. Years three and four pay $340,000 each, because $160,000 of stock vests in each.
Offer B runs the other way. Year one pays $337,000, with $152,000 of vested stock. Year two pays $313,000. Year three drops to $265,000. Year four drops to $225,000.
Add the years up as you go. After two years, Offer B has paid $650,000 and Offer A $545,000. Offer B is $105,000 ahead. After three years, Offer B still leads by $30,000. Offer A only wins if Jordan stays into year four. By the end of it, Offer A leads by $85,000.
So the better offer depends on how long Jordan expects to stay. The four-year average assumes Jordan stays all four years.
Refreshers can fill Offer B’s later years, but they aren’t in the letter
Offer B’s drop in years three and four looks harsh. Front-loaded companies expect refresher grants to fill it. A refresher is a new grant, often given after a yearly review.
The offer letter doesn’t promise one, though. A former Google recruiter wrote on Levels.fyi in September 2022 that managers plan refreshers each year. The same post says new hires are eligible after year one but rarely get them. That’s one recruiter’s view from four years ago. It still shows why you can’t count a refresher as pay.
So compare the offers without refreshers first. Then ask Offer B’s recruiter one direct question. How large was the typical first refresher at this level last cycle? If the answer is a number, you can plan around it. If it’s vague, plan as if no refresher comes.
The same question matters for Offer A. Its years three and four are strong. Year five has no grant at all. Whatever Jordan earns after year four depends on refreshers too.
Counter on the years where each offer is thin
Once the years are lined up, Jordan knows where each offer is thin. Offer A is thin in years one and two. Offer B is thin in years three and four. Each counter should target the thin years.
Say Jordan expects to stay about two years and prefers Offer A’s team. Asking Offer A for a bigger grant helps little. Most of any added grant would vest in years three and four. A bigger year-two sign-on closes the gap Jordan cares about. The cash also arrives in the window Jordan expects to be there.
Read the clawback before asking for more sign-on, though. A larger bonus may come with repayment terms. Our post on signing bonus clawback clauses covers what to change before you sign.
If Jordan planned to stay four years or more, the counter would flip. Jordan would ask Offer B for a larger grant, or for a written refresher target. A sign-on wouldn’t touch the years that are thin.
The email Jordan sends to Offer A’s recruiter
Jordan sends one email. It states Offer B’s numbers by year, then asks for one specific change. Our post on what the comp team does with a competing offer covers what happens next.
Hi Alex, thanks again for the offer. I’m excited about the team. I’d like to make this work.
I have a second offer with a front-loaded grant. Over the first two years it pays about $650,000 in base and vested stock. Your offer pays about $545,000 over the same two years, including the sign-on. The four-year totals are close. The gap is in years one and two.
Could the year-two sign-on go from $45,000 to $100,000? That would close about half of the early gap. If the grant is easier to move, how much of an increase would vest in year two?
Could you also confirm the vesting dates? I’d like to know how often shares vest in years three and four.
The email gives the recruiter one sum to approve. It also names the years that matter to Jordan. The recruiter can see that the request fits the gap and doesn’t stretch past it.
The last line asks for vesting dates. Shares vest on set dates. Then check the grant agreement for what happens to unvested shares if you leave. Jordan needs both answers to time any future move.
Check the tax on your biggest vest year before you sign
Offer A puts $160,000 of stock into each of years three and four. Ask how your vests are taxed and when. If they count as income in the year they vest, Jordan’s income jumps in those years.
Withholding may not keep up. If your employer treats a vest as supplemental wages, federal withholding can use a flat rate. IRS Publication 15 sets it at 22% for 2026. The rate rises to 37% above $1 million of supplemental wages in a year. If your top bracket is above 22%, the gap comes due when you file.
Offer B spreads more of its stock into the early years, so its biggest vest year comes first. Either way, ask the recruiter how the company withholds on vests. Ask whether you can choose a higher rate. Then talk to a tax professional about your own numbers.