When a recruiter asks for your competing offer letter, send the numbers first. Most of the time the recruiter needs figures to take to a compensation team. They need the base salary and bonus. They also need the equity, any sign-on bonus and the level. A written summary of those usually does the job. If they come back and say the team needs a document, send one. Make it the compensation section only, unedited, with a note saying what you left out. Never change a figure. If the other offer is still verbal, say so plainly. Then send the terms you heard. Reports in 2021 said Google recruiters had started asking engineers for written proof of rival offers. So treat it as a paperwork step with a clear owner. Answer the question the compensation team is asking. Don’t hand over every page you hold. Below is how that team reads an offer, three cases and a reply you can adapt.
The recruiter wants figures because someone above them has to approve the raise
Take an Android engineer we’ll call Omar. He’s finishing a loop at a large tech company. A fintech has already made him an offer for a senior Android role. He tells the big company’s recruiter about it and asks if they can do better. The recruiter’s reply comes the next day. “Happy to look at this. Can you send over the offer letter?”
Omar’s first reaction is to feel doubted. That reading is mostly wrong. In many large companies the recruiter can’t approve an offer above the level’s band alone. A compensation team or committee signs off. It wants evidence before it does.
Google is the best-documented case. In September 2021, Calcalist reported on a story from The Information. Google recruiters had started asking candidates who cited higher offers for a letter or a copy of one. The article says the practice had been common for non-technical roles. It had now spread to engineering roles. That report is from 2021, so the details may have changed. Google first judged whether a counter request was fair, the article says. Then it looked at the offer’s contents, including stock, salary and conditions. A headhunter quoted in the piece says Amazon and others had asked for this proof too.
So the request has a reader. That reader is a compensation analyst comparing two packages. Omar’s job is to give that person what the comparison needs and nothing more.
The compensation team compares five terms and two dates
An analyst comparing Omar’s two offers needs the parts that carry money and timing.
The first five terms cover the money. Base salary. The bonus target, as a percentage or an amount. The equity grant, with its vesting schedule. Any sign-on bonus, including whether it’s paid over two years. And the level or title, because the band depends on it.
The two dates cover timing. When the offer was made. When it expires. The expiry tells the recruiter how fast they need to move. A short deadline needs its own plan. Our post on handling an exploding offer while other loops run covers it.
Everything else in a letter is noise for this comparison. The benefits summary. Your home address. The hiring manager’s name. Restrictive covenants and at-will language. Relocation terms, unless they’re a real part of the money. None of it helps the analyst compare two numbers. Some of it is also the other company’s business, not yours to share.
Haseeb Qureshi made a related point in his 2016 guide to offer negotiation. He advises being open with recruiters while protecting information that would weaken your position. The guide is now ten years old. The principle still fits this request. Share what the comparison needs. Keep back what it doesn’t. It’s the same reason to decline when a recruiter asks for your current salary.
What you can send depends on which kind of offer you hold
Omar’s fintech offer could be in one of three states. Each one gets a different answer.
Say the offer is verbal. Some companies issue a written letter only after you say yes. If that’s Omar’s case, he has nothing to send. He should say so. Then he writes the terms in an email to the fintech recruiter. He asks them to confirm the numbers he heard. Qureshi’s guide also says you can push back when a recruiter moves offer talks off email. That confirmed email is honest proof. Omar can forward the relevant lines, or quote them, to the big company.
Say the offer is written and has no confidentiality line. Then Omar can send a document if the summary isn’t enough. He sends the page or section with the compensation table. He crops out the rest whole, instead of blacking out single words. Then he says in the email what he removed. A recruiter can check a crop against the summary. A page full of black bars invites the question of what’s under them.
Say the letter marks its terms as confidential. Omar should read that language before sending anything. If it covers the whole letter, he sends the summary only. He tells the recruiter why. “The letter asks me to keep its terms confidential, so I’ve listed the numbers instead.” That line gives the analyst the figures. It also explains the missing document without sounding evasive. This isn’t legal advice. If the stakes are high, ask an employment lawyer what the clause covers.
A reply when a recruiter asks for your competing offer letter
Here’s what Omar sends. The fintech’s offer is written, with no confidentiality line. Swap in your own numbers and company type.
“Thanks for looking at this. Here are the terms from the other offer. It’s for a Senior Android Engineer role. Base salary is [X]. The bonus target is [Y] percent. The equity grant is [Z] in RSUs, vesting over four years with a one-year cliff. There’s a sign-on bonus of [S], paid in the first year. The offer is dated October 12 and expires October 26. If your compensation team needs to see the document, I can send the page with the compensation table. I’d keep the rest of the letter private. Your company is my first choice. With a package at or above these terms, I’m ready to sign this week.”
Here’s why the reply is built this way. The opening thanks the recruiter, because they’re about to argue for Omar internally. The middle gives every figure the analyst needs, in the order a compensation table uses. Naming the role and level lets the team match it to their own band. The two dates show the deadline without making a threat of it. The offer to send one page answers the next request before it arrives. It also sets a limit. The last two sentences tell the recruiter that a matching package ends the process. That’s what lets a compensation team approve an exception.
An edited letter is worse than no letter at all
The one move that can cost Omar the offer is changing the document. That means rounding the base up, removing a vesting cliff or retyping the letter in his own format. A compensation analyst who sees many offers from one company will often know its format and bands. A changed figure that gets noticed doesn’t just lose the negotiation. It tells the recruiter Omar’s other numbers can’t be trusted either.
Qureshi’s guide puts the general rule plainly. “Don’t BS them or play stupid games.” Omar has already passed the loop. At this stage, the recruiter’s trust is most of what he can lose.
The same goes for inflating a verbal offer you can’t document. If the fintech said “around 200,” Omar writes “around 200,” not 210. A recruiter who later checks the number against market data will see the gap.
When the recruiter won’t move without the full letter
Sometimes the summary and the cropped page aren’t enough. The recruiter says the compensation team wants the whole letter, or no increase. Now Omar has to weigh the money against what the letter contains.
He can ask one clarifying question first. “Which part of the letter does the team need that the compensation page doesn’t show?” Sometimes the answer is a start date or a signature block. That’s easy to add. Sometimes there’s no answer. Then the request is a policy. The recruiter can’t bend it.
If it’s policy, Omar weighs two things. The first is how much the increase is likely to be worth. The second is whether the letter has anything he can’t share. If the letter is clean and the gap is large, sending it may be the practical call. If the letter has a confidentiality clause, he holds the line. Then he picks between the two offers as they stand. Either way, he decides once and tells the recruiter clearly. Going back and forth over a document wastes the time the expiry date left him.
1 thought on “Recruiter Asking for Your Competing Offer Letter? Send the Numbers First”