What to Say When a Recruiter Asks for Your Current Salary

Don’t give it. When a recruiter asks for your current salary, decline once, politely. Then give your expected range for the new role. In many places the recruiter isn’t allowed to ask at all. California’s salary history law bars employers from seeking an applicant’s pay history, including through an agent. Illinois says an agency recruiter can’t screen you on past pay either. The EU’s pay transparency directive bans the question too, once each country writes it into national law. Where the question is legal, you can still decline. The recruiter needs one fact from you. Will the company’s budget for this level cover what you want? Your expected range answers that. Your old paycheck doesn’t. Here’s a line that works almost anywhere. “I keep my current pay private. For this level, I’m targeting the top half of your posted range.” Below are the law, the full script and a fix if you already shared it.

Your current salary anchors the offer to your old job

Take an Android engineer we’ll call Dana. She earns a base salary well below market at a mid-size retailer. She applies for a senior Android role at a fintech company. The posting lists a range that starts above her current pay. On the first call, an agency recruiter asks a plain question. “What are you on at the moment?”

If Dana answers, her old salary becomes the reference point for the new offer. Patrick McKenzie made this argument in his 2012 guide to salary negotiation. He says your number becomes an anchor the employer can use to justify a low offer. A past salary works the same way. He calls “don’t give a number first” advice that is almost always right. That post is now more than a decade old. But the mechanism hasn’t changed. A company that knows Dana’s pay can offer her a raise. That offer can still sit low in its own band. She’d likely accept it, because it beats what she has.

Her current pay also says nothing about the role. It reflects her old company’s budget and her old level. The fintech’s band reflects the new job. That band is what the recruiter screens against.

In several US states the recruiter isn’t allowed to ask

California’s Labor Code section 432.3 says an employer can’t seek an applicant’s salary history, orally or in writing. That covers compensation and benefits. It also applies when the employer asks “through an agent,” so an outside recruiter is covered too. Employers with 15 or more employees must also post a pay scale with every job.

Illinois is more explicit about recruiters. The Illinois Department of Labor’s salary history ban FAQ names recruiters, employment agencies and staffing agencies. None of them may screen applicants on current or past pay. The FAQ also says an employer can’t hold it against you if you don’t answer. The page shows no publication date.

Those are two states among many. SHRM’s chief executive is Johnny C. Taylor Jr. He counted 22 states and 21 cities or localities with bans in a July 2022 column. That count is now more than four years old. So check the rule where the job is based before your first call.

One detail matters for Dana. California’s law still lets an applicant share pay history “voluntarily and without prompting.” So a ban protects you only if you don’t volunteer the number.

The EU banned the question too, but national law decides when

The EU’s pay transparency directive stops employers from asking applicants about their pay history. It also requires them to share the starting pay or range early enough for an informed negotiation. Member states had until 7 June 2026 to turn it into national law. Most missed that date. The employment law firm Lewis Silkin tracked progress in a July 2026 update. It listed Italy, Lithuania, Malta and Slovakia as fully transposed. Germany was still at the draft stage.

So an Android engineer interviewing in Munich or Amsterdam may hear the question for a while yet. The answer below works whether or not a law backs you up.

Where the question is legal, decline once and answer the real question

In the July 2022 column, Taylor says answering is usually the easiest way through the process. He’s right that refusing has a small cost. A recruiter screening dozens of candidates may move on from one who seems difficult. So don’t just refuse. Decline in one short sentence, then give the recruiter what they actually need.

What they need is a budget check. Our post on how the Android recruiter screen sets your level covers this. The recruiter is checking whether your pay expectations fit the band for the level. An expected range answers that directly. A past salary only answers it by guesswork.

The range also needs to match the level you’re targeting. If Dana anchors to her current pay, she can signal a lower level than the role. That leads to the problem in our post on getting a downleveled offer.

A script for the recruiter who asks what you’re on now

Here’s what Dana can say. Swap in your own range and the posting’s numbers.

“I keep my current compensation private. I’d rather the offer reflect this role than my last one. Your posting lists a range for the senior level. Based on the scope we’ve discussed, I’m looking at the upper half of that range in total compensation. Is that workable for the level you’re considering me for?”

Each sentence has a job. The first declines without apology or a reference to the law. A legal citation on a first call sounds like a threat. The second gives a reason the recruiter can write in their notes. The third points to a number the company published itself. So Dana isn’t inventing a figure. The fourth gives the recruiter the budget answer they called for. The last question hands the call back to them. It also asks them to confirm the level. The level is what sets her offer.

If there’s no posted range, Dana can ask for the band first. Then she names her own range only if the recruiter won’t share one. She sets its floor at the lowest total compensation she’d accept.

Some recruiters push again. One more short line usually ends it. “I understand. I’m not sharing it. The range I gave is accurate for what I’d accept.” If they still insist, that tells Dana something about how the offer stage will go.

If the recruiter asks for your current salary and you already shared it

You can still move the anchor. Don’t take the number back, because that sounds evasive. Separate it from the new role instead.

“That figure reflects my current level and my current company’s budget. For a senior role at your scope, I’m targeting the range we just discussed.”

Then repeat that range at every later stage, including the offer call. The recruiter’s notes will hold both numbers. Make sure the expected range is the one you keep using.

Application forms are the other place this slips out. Some include a current salary field. If a ban covers the job, leave it blank. Or write your expected range if the field takes text. Then mention it to the recruiter on the first call. Illinois goes further than most. Its FAQ says employers can’t rely on pay history even when you volunteer it. Most places don’t go that far, so leave the field empty where you can.

Leave a Comment